South African police opened fire Thursday on a crowd of striking miners that charged a line of officers trying to disperse them, killing some and wounding others in one of the worst shootings by authorities since the end of the apartheid era.
Police declined to offer casualty figures after the shooting at the Lonmin PLC mine near Marikana, a dusty town about 70 kilometers northwest of Johannesburg. However, the main South African news agency, SAPA, has reported that 18 people have been killed. Police ministry spokesman Zweli Mnisi acknowledged late Thursday some of the miners there had died as more police and soldiers surrounded the hostels and shacks near Lonmin’s shuttered platinum mine.
The shooting happened Thursday afternoon after police failed to get the striking miners to hand over machetes, clubs and other weapons.
Some miners did leave, though others carrying weapons began war chants and soon started marching toward the township near the mine, said Molaole Montsho, a journalist with the South African Press Association who was at the scene.
The police opened up with a water cannon first, then used stun grenades and tear gas to try and break up the crowd, Mr. Montsho said.
Suddenly, a group of miners rushed through the underbrush and tear gas at a line of police officers. Officers immediately opened fire, with miners falling to the ground. Dozens of shots were fired by police armed with automatic rifles and pistols.
Images broadcast by private television broadcaster e.tv showed the gunfire ending with police officers shouting “cease fire!” By that time, bodies were lying in the dust, some pouring blood. Another image showed some miners, their eyes wide, looking in the distance at heavily armed police officers in riot gear.
It was an astonishing development in a country that has been a model of stability since racist white rule ended with South Africa’s first all-race elections in 1994. The shooting recalled images of white police firing at anti-apartheid protesters in the 1960s and 1970s, but in this case it was mostly black police firing at black mine workers.
President Jacob Zuma said he was “shocked and dismayed at this senseless violence.”
“We believe there is enough space in our democratic order for any dispute to be resolved through dialogue without any breaches of the law or violence,” he said in a statement.
Barnard O. Mokwena, an executive vice president at Lonmin, would say only: “It’s a police operation.” Lonmin is the world’s third largest platinum producer
In a statement earlier Thursday, Lonmin had said striking workers would be sacked if they did not appear at their shifts Friday.
“The striking (workers) remain armed and away from work,” the statement read. “This is illegal.”
The unrest at the Lonmin mine began Aug. 10, as some 3,000 workers walked off the job over pay in what management described as an illegal strike. Those who tried to go to work on Saturday were attacked, management and the National Union of Mineworkers said.
On Sunday, the rage became deadly as a crowd killed two security guards by setting their car ablaze, authorities said. By Monday, angry mobs killed two other workers and overpowered police, killing two officers, officials said. Officers opened fire that day, killing three others, police said.
Tuesday and Wednesday, thousands of miners had gathered at a rocky cliff within sight of the mine’s smelter. They cheered, sang and marched around with machetes and clubs under the watchful eye of police officers in armored trucks. Some leaders of the miners spoke with the police and largely followed their instructions, breaking up the protest as dusk fell.
Operations appeared to come to a standstill Tuesday as workers stayed away from the mines, where 96 percent of all Lonmin’s platinum production comes from. The stoppage has spooked those investing in Lonmin. Stock in Lonmin plunged 7.27 percent in trading Thursday afternoon on the London Stock Exchange.
While the walkout appeared to be about wages, the ensuing violence has been fueled by the struggles between the dominant National Union of Mineworkers and the upstart Association of Mineworkers and Construction Union. Disputes between the two unions escalated into violence earlier this year at another mine.
Black miners long have faced low salaries and poor living conditions in shantytowns often beset by alcoholism, drug abuse and prostitution. Apartheid kept black African workers from more lucrative jobs offered to whites. Though the nation became truly democratic in the 1990s, the salaries of black miners remain low.
Mining drives the economy of South Africa, which remains one of the world’s dominant producers of platinum, gold and chromium. Lonmin is the world’s third largest platinum producer and its mine at Marikana produces 96 per cent of all its platinum. The violence has shaken the precious metals market, as platinum futures ended up $39, or 2.8 per cent, at $1,435.20 an ounce in trading Thursday on the New York Mercantile Exchange.
Statistics: Posted by yoda — Thu Aug 16, 2012 3:51 pm
View full post on opinions.caduceusx.com
Black is White, Hedges are Bets, and Your Money is Mine (guest essay)
June 14, 2012
Once again we turn to frequent contributor Zeus Yiamouyiannis for a sharp analysis of why our "profits are private, losses are public" crony-capitalism is self-destructing and what is needed to move forward to a sustainable, adaptable, wealth-generating capitalism.
As we witness the riotous dissolution of corrupted capitalism, we need not wait for the history books to identify the mile markers of self-destruction. If we are to rebuild capitalism, even as it is tearing itself down, then we will need to become street-smart detectives in analyzing the current economic murder-suicide in progress.
Every fall has its tell-tale confirmations and corrupt capitalism is no exception. There arrive key points where a system’s own contradictions become so evident and self-damaging, where motive, means, and opportunity become so clear, that one can mount an informed, effective counter-offensive.
Two notable recent contradictions have surfaced in the ongoing debacle called big banking.
1) Hedges for big banks have evolved into gambling vehicles that increase risk rather than reduce risk.
2) Guaranteed savings deposits in those same big banks are being used as fodder in the high-risk investment casinos of global finance. There are no longer effective firewalls or truly secure funds.
Capitalism now means big banks profit from their so-called successes, and others pay for their failures: “Black is white.” JP Morgan has recently lost $3 billion dand counting on a ‘sure thing’: “Hedges are bets.” Investment banks are now merged with conventional banking and secured by taxpayer and depositor money: “Your money is mine.”
These capitalist tumors grow from assumptions that all gains shall be privatized, all stakes shall be “other people’s money,” and all liabilities will fall upon the patsies formerly known as represented citizens.
Everything for reckless, ill-gotten profit; nothing for prudent management
I felt like I was in the twilight zone when reading a New York Times anatomy of JP Morgan’s recent multi-billion dollar losses on some of its hedge positions.
First, these so-called hedge positions were never designed as buffers against loss. They were driven by greed, risk, and desire for profit. Genuine hedges are supposed to buffer against, rather than accentuate, loss, excess, and unwise decision-making.
“What this hedge morphed into violates our own principles,” said JP Morgan CEO Jamie Dimon, citing their recent multi-billion dollar loss. “Morphed into?” C’mon! You played the market from the start. This was no hedge. It was a gamble, and one that you lost. Capitalism that relies upon sound judgment is apparently a throwback to the time when consequences fell upon the company making bad decisions.
Ironically, the more traders stampede to a “sure profit” in certain hedges, the riskier they get. With the advent of high frequency trading and hyper-speed information access, these stampedes are more likely to occur. Risk is also amplified by converse positions. In today’s reality, those who bet against these “sure profit” moves can now employ methods to enhance their position by artificially manipulating buying and selling (naked shorts anyone?). Prospective gold mines can quickly turn into dry holes.
Nobody seems to learn when there are no meaningful consequences. Almost the same exact scenario befell Long Term Capital Management (LCTM). Both LCTM in 1998 and JP Morgan in 2012 bet on the “sure” convergence of newly issued and older treasury bond interest rates, hoping to amplify a small but relatively guaranteed profit into a huge profit by creating a large position through leveraged borrowing.
This very action and the actions of others piling on actually increased divergences by straining the Treasury market. Leveraged hedges built around amplified, “safe” profits create a fertile climate for significantly increased risk and billions of dollars of loss.
Genuine hedges increase operating profit over time by anticipating and reducing possible loss. These latest hedge mutations used by JP Morgan and others have sought to increase profit directly through betting. By using access to data and resources that others now share in the information age, LCTM and JP Morgan failed to anticipate the effects their very actions would have on the market. They needed a genuine hedge against their mutated hedge. (Maybe they should have consulted Goldman Sachs, the experts in betting against their own advice and their own customers for profit.)
When moves to create stability and safety are themselves more gambling, there is no coherence to the system, no buffer, no feedback loop. Excess is rewarded and prudence is punished. With such an operating premise, finance can only spiral into a senseless spectacle. The din is still off in the distance but getting louder as the hounds of reality refuse to be kept at bay.
Savings deposits in big banks have effectively become market casino fodder
Investment involves gambling plain and simple. Risk-return assets are not simply product purchases. If investment were just a consumable, the buyer would use the product for personal needs and see its value depreciate gradually through use. Investors have much different expectations. They are seeking a stake in an enterprise, not just a product, that will generate financial return and appreciate in value. However, this enterprise can also lose its value and leave the investor with nothing.
Even entrepreneurs who invest in their own business, as laudable as that may be, are gambling. They can lose their money for a variety of reasons, even if their business plans are well conceived, organized, and executed. There should be no guarantees with investment except those legal protections against fraud, theft, abuse, manipulation, and corruption that maintain a free enterprise system of risk and return on a transparent, accountable, and enforceable playing field. Bad luck, bad timing, and even bad management are all a fair part of free enterprise.
What happens, however, when big banks, unleashed by the abolishment of the Glass-Steagall Act, are allowed to link their unregulated investment gambling activity with regulated and guaranteed deposit taking? A sham of a free enterprise system emerges, where public funds and guaranteed private savings are nothing more than backstopping fodder for irresponsible gambling.
Here is the key question: Is money that I deposit to a bank, money that I give to a bank? The big bank’s answer is, “Yes. We will use your money or lose it any way we choose.” My answer is, “No. Deposit means deposit. I am not lending it. I am not investing it. I am not agreeing to get a below-inflation return so I can lose my money outright. (For a too-close-for-comfort parody on this see: The Important of Saving Money)
Savings is supposed to be secure dollar storage in a financial lending service. In consideration for lenders circulating my deposited funds at higher interest, I am given a modest user fee. I am parking my money with a bank or credit union to use in safe, vigilantly underwritten lending activities. The lending institutions I patronize garner a higher interest return than they are paying out to me. Interest rates they charge others vary to compensate for default risk. Of course this does not maximize profit! It maximizes stability. That’s its purpose, and that is the purpose of guaranteeing my deposit.
This is why savings is distinct from investment. Investment is a gamble. Its purpose is to maximize profit (including minimizing loss) by wisely supporting enterprises that are managed well and that return well. At least that is the way it is supposed to be. Not so today. Big banks are treating my deposit money like an investment in a greed-driven empire with no upside for me. If banks’ stocks go up, I’m not getting a dividend. If these banks go bankrupt through unwise or unlucky gambling, either I don’t get my money back, or taxpayers ending up bearing the costs.
The global financial system has turned into a rigged Las Vegas minus the neon. Instead of the gambling addict going broke and being escorted out of the casino, my livelihood and my children’s is being put on the table to allow these addicts not only to win back their money but make a killing in the process. (Of course big banks are also the gambling houses themselves, as well as the addicts, charging fees for every transaction, giving themselves hundreds of billions of dollars in bonuses, and skimming profits.)
This same condition extends not just to savings, but to the way assets and future public entitlement payments are being annexed through taxpayer bailouts and increased national debt. In fact, the present and future wealth of the entire planet is being put up for chips. “Don’t worry,” say the big banks in a slurred voice, “My rich uncles, the central banks, will make good. Deal me another hand! Hey, bring on mortgages and Social Security and put them on the betting block too.”
We are so far down the rabbit hole that even reinstituting Glass-Steagall will not be sufficient. Big banks are simply reshuffling practices in such a way that investment banking is not labeled as such. Enforced separation between investment brokering and traditional deposit taking means little if I can simply "rename" my investment brokering as something else or if I can classify my deposit taking so it is guaranteed by the FDIC even as I funnel and gamble that money. Heads I win, tails you lose again.
What can be done
The answer to this hijacking of private savings and public funds is public refusal to redeem gambling debts. This can be done in several ways:
Financially, citizens en masse need to coordinate taking their money out of corrupt big banks and put that money into financially strong community banks and credit unions that don’t gamble with other people’s money. If I decide to gamble with my own money with a bank-serviced investment portfolio, fine. If an investment bank decides to gamble, it can use its own capital and not mine. If I decide to let a hedge fund gamble my money for me, I should be prepared to lose it all.
Politically, we need to push for an enforced law with a very simple rule: “No public guarantees for private gambling” and do a much better job of ensuring that no guarantees of public funds go to any activity that is even associated with investment gambling.
We could charter and support state or regional banks from the national level to provide low-cost liquidity (an alternative “Fed window) to small banks and credit unions–organizations that actually make their money lending prudently to communities and enhancing the economic health of the nation and local populations. These organizations would then more effectively compete with the current corporate financial monopolies holding this country hostage.
Policy-wise, we could limit counter-party risk and the systemic damage caused by Big Finance’s investment gambling. (Karl Denninger has a good suggestion in these two posts: Why The JPM Trade Matters and Solution: ONE DOLLAR OF CAPITAL). Denninger’s "One Dollar of Capital" rule would “Prohibit as a matter of Federal Law… the lending of money unsecured that exceeds the firm’s capital.” However, if firms, like MF Global, can gamble with segregated customer accounts as if these accounts were their own money, this suggestion won’t work for a particular bank or investment company. Hence the need for the previous strategies.
We have a long way to go, but the hounds of reality strain closer. Instead of running from them, let’s grab their leashes and turn the hounds on the banks.
By Zeus Yiamouyiannis, Ph.D.
Statistics: Posted by yoda — Thu Jun 14, 2012 9:16 am
View full post on opinions.caduceusx.com
Implats loses 80,000 oz to date at Rustenburg
By Sherilee Lakmidas |
JOHANNESBURG (Reuters) – Impala Platinum, the world’s second largest platinum producer, said on Monday that a violent labour dispute at its flagship Rustenburg operations has cost it 80,000 ounces in lost production to date.
The stoppage, now in its fifth week, is costing 20,000 ounces a week but the company said its capital projects remained "largely unaffected" by the unfolding drama around the mine, where violence has claimed the lives of two miners.
The Rustenburg operations lie 120 km (80 miles) northwest of Johannesburg and are the world’s largest platinum producing mines, accounting for some 15 percent of global supply.
Operations were brought to halt after over 17,000 striking rock drill operators and other mineworkers were dimissed and the rehiring process failed to secure enough mineworkers to restart the shafts.
Around 7,800 workers, including over 900 rock drill operators, have since been re-hired but the operation needs at least 2,000 rock drill operators to restart production.
Implats management said in a statement the majority of employees want to return to work, but "unprecedented levels of intimidation and violence" were preventing them from doing so.
South Africa’s mines minister Susan Shabangu said the police needed to stamp out the intimidation, in her first public comments on the issue.
"I think what is happening at the Impala mine, it cannot be allowed to continue. It’s not good for workers who are keen to work but are being intimidated," she said.
"We appeal to the police to take decisive action where there is intimidation," she told Reuters near the town of Ventersdorp, while visiting the family of a female mineworker who was murdered underground in an unrelated incident.
The dispute has centered on a bonus offered only part of the workforce but has escalated into a struggle between competing unions.
Implats on Monday again blamed one union, the Association of Mineorkers and Construction Union, for stirring a hornet’s nest as rock drill operators reject the dominant National Union of Mineworkers (NUM).
"We have seen the emergence of a rival new union, the AMCU," Implats said.
Implats said "criminal attacks" on its property and the NUM membership had been extended to communities around the mine which have been the scene of rioting and looting.
The South Afrcan police confirmed that a second miner had been killed in a standoff on Sunday night.
Regional police spokesman Thulani Ngubane said a riot started on Sunday when 600 men went house-to-house through a township trying to force others to join them in a vandalism spree at the mine.
"Their intention was to take them to the mineshaft. The police struggled to disperse the crowd," said Ngubane. The dead man had been shot, and another was found with a bullet wound in the thigh, he added.
Statistics: Posted by yoda — Mon Feb 20, 2012 1:42 pm
View full post on opinions.caduceusx.com
Impala Fires 17,200 Workers at Platinum Mine
By Carli Lourens and Jana Marais – Feb 2, 2012
Impala Platinum Holdings Ltd. (IMP), producer of about a quarter of global platinum, fired 17,200 workers after an illegal pay strike halted its Rustenburg mine, the world’s biggest for the metal.
The number includes 13,000 employees who joined the stoppage, declared illegal by court order, after they failed to return to work by yesterday’s deadline, the Johannesburg-based company said in a statement today. The strike is costing Impala about 3,000 ounces of platinum daily, the equivalent of $4.9 million in sales a day.
The Rustenburg operation, northwest of Johannesburg, accounts for half of Impala’s total production and about two- thirds of its profit. The mine produced 941,200 ounces in Impala’s last fiscal year. South Africa is the world’s largest producer of the metal used in car components and jewelery.
Impala fell 2.5 percent to 170.68 rand by the close of Johannesburg trading, compared with larger rival Anglo American Platinum Ltd. (AMS)’s 0.5 percent decline.
Disruptions at the mine, which employed 46,653 permanent and contract workers last year, started on Jan. 20 when about 5,000 rock-drill operators began a strike over pay. They were dismissed. By Jan. 26, about 15 percent of them returned to work at the mine.
The strike widened this week when the majority of staff didn’t report for duty, Impala said Jan. 30, adding the Association of Mineworkers and Construction Union, which isn’t formally recognized by Impala, “attempted to gain recognition” at the mine.
The National Union of Mineworkers, which represents most Impala workers and is recognized by the company, dispatched a team “to help normalize the situation,” NUM spokesman Lesiba Seshoka said yesterday.
“It will be a very big battle,” Seshoka said, and production is unlikely to resume soon.
The Congress of South African Trade Unions, whose NUM affiliate represents most employees at the operation, asked Impala to reinstate the jobs.
“A process of rehiring for those employees who wish to reapply for their positions will be undertaken in due course,” Impala said today.
Jeff Mphahlele, general secretary for the Association of Mineworkers and Construction Union, which represents some of the rock drill operators, couldn’t immediately comment when reached by mobile phone. Dumisani Nkalitshana, the union’s national organizer, didn’t respond to a message left on his mobile phone.
Rock-drill operators went on strike because they weren’t given the same pay increases other categories of worker were awarded, Seshoka said yesterday.
Statistics: Posted by yoda — Thu Feb 02, 2012 2:15 pm
View full post on opinions.caduceusx.com